Top quality supplies, fair prices

Shop now

Top 10 Best Sellers

Regular Card Sleeves (100 count)
$ 1.99
35 pt Toploader (25 count)
$ 3.99
35 pt Toploader (200 count) with Sleeves COMBO Packs
$ 29.99
Semi-Rigid Card Holder #1 (3⁵⁄₁₆'' x 4⁷⁄₈'') (50 count)
from $ 6.99
35 pt Toploader (100 count) with Sleeves COMBO Packs
$ 16.99
Promo card inside a 35 point magnetic card holder against a white background.
35 pt Magnetic Card Holder
from $ 2.49
Perfect Fit PSA Graded Card Sleeves (100 count)
from $ 4.99
Superior Card Sleeves (100 count)
$ 2.49
Available in eleven vibrant colors (black, silver, red, blue, pink, light blue, yellow, purple, gold, green, and orange), The Pennysleever’s aluminum cases for PSA and CGC slabs feature a durable, secure magnetic closure to ensure your slab stays protected.
The Pennysleever’s silver aluminum case for PSA and CGC slabs showcases a vintage‑style Ken Griffey Jr. card inside and is engineered with a strong, secure magnetic closure to keep your slab protected.
PSA/CGC Aluminum Case
$ 22.99
Black 9 pocket card collectors album with 'PENNYSLEEVER' logo on a white background
9 Pocket Premium Album
$ 19.99
View all
View all
10 products
An angled view of a full pack of 360 point toploaders against a white background.

Toploaders

SHOP NOW
130 point magnetic card holder at a 45 degree angle with a white background.

Magnetic Card Holder

SHOP NOW
A pack of 100 thick card sleeves against a white background.

More items here

Regular & Thick Card Sleeves, Semi-Rigid Card Holders & Team Bags
Shop now

All Sizes

All Sizes